Goldstone Scientific Blog

Prizmatix’s Advice on Light Meters for Optogenetics

Posted by

I am often asked to recommend light meters to use for testing the fiber optic implants that will be used in Optogenetic experiments. This is important in order to test the quality of each implant and make sure everything is working correctly.

Measuring the light correctly is not a trivial matter. The meter setting, the detector and the way the measurement is taken all makes a difference.

The light emitted from high NA fibers is highly divergent. Most photodiode-based laser power meters are expecting the light to hit perpendicular to the sensor. But light from LEDs and high NA fibers hit the sensor surface at an angle. As a result, a standard laser power meter will be underestimate the light emitted by a high NA fiber by up to 25-30% (for NA0.66 fibers). The best solution is to use an integrating sphere detector and power meter.  The integrating sphere  averages the various ray angles and provides a theoretically correct power value that does not depend on ray direction.   

Many of our customers use Thorlabs power meters and we purchased one so we can “be on the same page” as our customers. Which Thorlabs meter do we recommend?

Here is a cut and paste about light meters from a Prizmatix engineer:

For best measurements of LED we recommend detector with an integrating sphere and not the common laser power meters with the flat detectors.

We recommend spending more on the detector and less on the meter.

We recently started using:

(Some customers use a lower cost detector with one inch sphere but it is more difficult to get correct and consistent reading since it is more sensitive to the angle and position of the fiber)

Even with proper equipment, it is easy to get wrong readings. In a coming blog I will post our engineers advice about how to get correct power reading when using an integrating sphere.

View Comments

High NA Fiber Optics for In-Vivo Optogenetics – The Options on Goldstone Scientific

Quality fiber optic implants are crucial for successful in-vivo Optogenetics. Scientists will need to spend time or money (or both) to ensure quality results. Prizmatix offers a range of options and Goldstone Scientific makes it easy to order and offers competitive prices with bulk discounts and fast shipping to save you both. Many items are [...]

Read More »

Light Meters, Fiber Optics and Optogenetics – Part 1 – Light Meter Blues

Prizmatix LEDs are extremely powerful and our customers are generally very satisfied with their performance.  Sometime, however, I get complaints about the power output being lower than expected as per the published specification. Very frequently it turns out that the light source is fine, and the problem lies within the tools and methods used to measure the power. In [...]

Read More »

Prizmatix Fiber Optic Rotary Joint; Compatibility of with Lasers or other light sources

The Prizmatix Fiber Optic Rotary Joint is an important part of the Prizmatix  In-Vivo Optognetics Toolbox. It’s extremely low torque (<10μNm) allows even the smallest animals to move freely and its high transmission is helpful in getting as much power as possible to the target. One really nice feature of the Prizmatix fiber optic rotary joint is that it can be used [...]

Read More »

Do LEDs have enough power for In-Vivo Optogenetics?

Do LEDs have enough power for In-Vivo Optogenetics?  It depends who you ask. Often, while talking to researchers considering LED for Optogenetics, I hear “People tell me that LEDs just don’t have enough power, especially for inhibition”. That is a real concern. In fact a competing vendor of LEDs for Optogenetics told me that their light sources do not have enough power, [...]

Read More »

Med Associates introduces new Optogenetic Fear Conditioning System at SfN 2014 booth #2732

Prizmatix is excited to have their Ultra High Power Optogenetic-LED combined with the popular Med Associates Fear Condition System. This great new combination is available from Med Associates and comes with everything you need from the LED to the fiber implant! As usual, one Prizmatix LED can be used to deliver powerful LED light to two implants for bilateral stimulation, [...]

Read More »

Tissue Heating During Optogenetic Experiments Using Laser and LEDs

During a recent LinkedIn conversation regarding light sources for Optogenetics a concern was raised about LEDs causing heating of the tissue. The concern was based on information in a paper “Optogenetics in Neural Systems” published by O Yizhar et al., Neuron, 2011. A careful reading of this paper shows that the concern is relevant only to small LEDs implanted in the tissue, [...]

Read More »

Illumination Inside of an Incubator for Optogenetics or Phototoxicity Research

One challenging application we get asked about occasionally is illumination inside of an incubator. These hot, humid and often crowded conditions make it difficult to deliver high intensity light. In one instance, a cardiology researcher using Optogenetics needed intense blue light over an area of microwells to activate channelrhodopsin. There were a number of reasons not to place the Ultra [...]

Read More »

​What is Numerical Aperture (NA) and why would a neuroscientist need to know?

Someone once told me that neuroscientists are exceptional. Neuroscientists are not afraid of integrating many areas of knowledge and technology into their research and methods. Well, I can certainly say that neuroscientists have a lot of puzzle pieces to put together to get their research going. And with Optogenetics becoming more widespread I find myself explaining a lot about [...]

Read More »